When the economy falters, so does public support for climate action.

click to enlarge, sources provided below, PDF here, image here

Climate activists want to shut down the economy. They want to throw coal miners, oil workers, livestock farmers, and airline employees out of work. But when jobs start disappearing, public support for climate action drops sharply. And vice versa.

The above graph shows 13 years of data gathered by US polling company, Pew Research. I’ve discussed this research elsewhere. It tracks the percentage of the American population that considers climate change a ‘top priority’ relative to other issues.

This data can be confusing because every item on the long list that Pew reads to those being polled is considered a ‘top priority’ by some portion of the population. Isolating two topics helps bring matters into focus. In this graph, the percentage of people who think the economy should be a top priority are represented by the blue bars. The percentage who think the climate should be a top priority are represented by the red ones.

Poll results must always be taken with a grain of salt. Surveys can be skewed from the outset. Their methodology can be biased. Their results are subject to cherry picking. (For an example of all three, see my critique here.)

Nevertheless, polls are an important source of data about what the wider population thinks – as opposed to what journalists and political activists think.

It would seem that something rather obvious is going on. When people are worried about finding a job and paying their bills, there’s less room in their heads and hearts for hypothetical concerns.

Relative to Pew’s long list of other issues, climate change always ranks near the bottom or dead last. It has never been an urgent priority for a large percentage of the American public. Individuals may say they’re concerned about the climate, but they’re more concerned about practically everything else.

Attention climate activists: Public support for climate measures appears to be closely connected to a strong, healthy, growing economy. Policies that undermine the economy are therefore counterproductive.

.

If what you’ve just read is useful or helpful,
please support this blog

LINKS & INFO:

• the numbers in these graphs were culled from Pew poll results: 2007-2013 (interactive, select a year and click ‘overall’), 2013-2016 here, see bottom of page for 2017 and 2018 data, results for 2019 are here
• terrorism was identified as a top priority by the highest percentage of Americans in the Pew poll during 2007, 2015, 2017, and 2018
• the economy was identified as the top priority by the highest percentage of Americans 2008-2014, in 2016, and in 2019
• the Environmental Kuznet’s curve
• see my previous commentary, Poll Results: Climate Is Always Low Priority
• Decades of Public Opinion: Climate Change Not on the Radar
• from 2014, The Climate Change Express: Ignoring Your Views at Every Meal
• from 2010, The Activists, the Poll, and the Data

.